[MERGED] Farming with Henchmen

4 pages • Page 1
C
Cobalt
Krytan Explorer
• #1
I kept count and set a goal of 50 boss kills trying to get one of the new green items never got a one. Drops from bosses were so bad I got one plain icon drop in the last 20 boss kills 3 drops total in 50 boss kills. 2 plain items and one scroll of insight, just disgusting.

I sure hope others are having better luck than myself.
V
VendrenWorm
Ascalonian Squire
• #2
You got one with henchmen? I've experienced the same thing. No green drops with hench at all. They drop way too often while playing with other people for it to be just bad luck.
K
KuTeBaka
Wilds Pathfinder
• #3
they always drop one green item when they are killed, you are just really unlucky or maybe they dont drop with henchies. just go with other people.
S
Scaper-X
Frost Gate Guardian
• #4
Remember, when you go with a full contingent of henchmen, you've only a 12.5% chance of getting any drop. Also, if you're continually farming the same boss(es), perhaps they also suffer from "drop anxiety" and will stop releasing their unique to you (see: Hill Giant farming).

Regardless, I've done the same (taking only four or five henchmen) and have managed one green drop. *shrug*
-- Scaper-X
Detis Zan
Detis Zan
Lion's Arch Merchant
• #5
I killed an Ice boss with all henchmen and got a single green item that sold for 19k and two shards. =P The guy just offered it and I couldn't refuse.
Intricated
Intricated
Ascalonian Squire
• #6
I took a full set of henchies as I pretty much explored all areas of Sorrow's Furnace over a period of 2 hours or so. Other than finishing 2 quests, dying at least 12 times, 3 gold armor drops, and a few purple/blue ones, I managed to get 1 green drop (a pretty nice curse-based staff) on the final boss I encountered out of the 8 or 9 that I came across.

So I am a bit inclined to believe that going with other players at least makes it look like green items drop more often. But maybe it just wasn't my day.
I
IlikeGW
Jungle Guide
• #7
henches give the most skewed impression because drops are invisible. maybe they all were enjoying greens.
K
Kampfkeks
Krytan Explorer
• #8
Quote: Originally Posted by KuTeBaka
they always drop one green item when they are killed, you are just really unlucky or maybe they dont drop with henchies. just go with other people. Now that is not true. I've been killing a few with a friend of mine and no green weapon dropped. We did not have any other person on our team, just us two... so no they don't allways drop.
I
IlikeGW
Jungle Guide
• #9
Yes, they most definitely don't always drop. The rate seems high, like 30%, but it's not a given.
B
Bingley Joe
Lion's Arch Merchant
• #10
I got one. But it's the only one I've seen in a day of playing. Myself and a buddy with a party of henchies.

Was funny too, because on that run, I got a TON of great stuff - way more than I normally get - and he kept getting stuff like plain near-max Raven Staffs ;P

When that green dropped there was some nasty stuff coming through on Skype, let me tell you!
Racthoh
Racthoh
Did I hear 7 heroes?
• #11
I'm getting piles of about 100 gold, normal white shields, and other junk both in and outside of Sorrow's Furnace. I'm only using 4 henchmen and myself in hopes that their drops odds will increase because I want to see the green sword.
Detis Zan
Detis Zan
Lion's Arch Merchant
• #12
Quote: Originally Posted by Racthoh
I'm getting piles of about 100 gold, normal white shields, and other junk both in and outside of Sorrow's Furnace. I'm only using 4 henchmen and myself in hopes that their drops odds will increase because I want to see the green sword. Heya Rac long time no play.

I agree, I've taken only 4 henchies and myself included to get better items.

question do the supieor IDs are better than the regular ones? Like the higher chance to unlock better mods on a unid item?
Y
Yemen
Academy Page
• #13
Quote: Originally Posted by Detis Zan
question do the supieor IDs are better than the regular ones? Like the higher chance to unlock better mods on a unid item? No, its just bigger one, not any better.
Numa Pompilius
Numa Pompilius
Grotto Attendant
• #14
FWIW...

I cruised the desert and south shiverpeaks with 2 henches yesterday, killing everything, then cleared out witmans folly and the troll cave in talos chute, and the drops were PITIFUL.

You know the drops are bad when you _lose_ 140 gold killing everything in witmans folly just because you open one chest, and clearing the troll cave gives 200 gold, one white non-max bow, and one non-max raven staff.

Then, in desperation, I switched to my W/Mo farmer, and did some solo farming. The drops seemed to be about normal.

Unless I was just extremely unlucky, they've increased the share of drops for henchmen. Very nasty if they have, as it makes some classes (especially mesmers) nearly impossible to solo.
Starsky-sama
Starsky-sama
Forge Runner
• #15
Quote: Originally Posted by Cobalt
I kept count and set a goal of 50 boss kills trying to get one of the new green items never got a one. Drops from bosses were so bad I got one plain icon drop in the last 20 boss kills 3 drops total in 50 boss kills. 2 plain items and one scroll of insight, just disgusting.

I sure hope others are having better luck than myself. the thing you need to keep track of when using henchies is, that how many kills before you see your drop. You could try and count and then kill the boss when you think it's your drop time. (but again something crappy or money may just come out)

its pretty much random and luck anyways.

First time going through GrenthsPath, I met Yakslapper and Thornbeard w/ full (7)hench. I got nothing from YakSlap. and a green bow from Thornb.

I think when ppl try their hardest in trying to get something ingame, it's most likely it wont drop, but when you dont think about it, it's usually that time it can actually drop. (happens to me alot, since I farm)

*next time dont think how many bosses and just keep doing it. It's just really luck of the farming system.

-GL.
C
Cobalt
Krytan Explorer
• #16
Quote: Originally Posted by Numa Pompilius
FWIW...

Unless I was just extremely unlucky, they've increased the share of drops for henchmen. Very nasty if they have, as it makes some classes (especially mesmers) nearly impossible to solo.
It is entirely possible that is exactly what they did in yet another attempt to deter solo farming even with henches.

When I did my 50 boss kill run I mention in the first post, I cleared a majority of the area outside War camp and the 5 bosses each time. I picked up what little drops even the plain stuff I got but they were so few that I never had to stop and sell stuff because my inventory never got full.
d
darkspenser
Pre-Searing Cadet
• #17
You shouldn't be farming at all to begin with.
If you bring henches you shouldn't be expecting drops.

I brought 8 henches and cleared out most of the furnace. I got two green bows (exact same item) off one boss.

I guess you just have to be lucky. If you want your drop rate improved, try using less (or no) henches.
Homo
Homo
Ascalonian Squire
• #18
Patients my man. In 6 hours I got 9 green items and 5 scrolls droped with a full henchie team.
A
Alcaza Bedabra
Academy Page
• #19
I think it's pretty much random, guys.

I've gone out with 7 henches, killed about 20 bosses, and come back with 2 greens.

Luck?

Or did they nerf the areas I was farming in one of the mini after-updates that they did? There were like five of those, they were likely tweaking those drops in response to a huge surge of farmers.

Whaddaya bet that Anet got a little shock when about a third of the population of GW suddenly came puring out of Deldrimor War Camp and started farming bosses?
Andy_M
Andy_M
Wilds Pathfinder
• #20
Quote: Originally Posted by Alcaza Bedabra
I think it's pretty much random, guys.

I've gone out with 7 henches, killed about 20 bosses, and come back with 2 greens.

Luck?

Or did they nerf the areas I was farming in one of the mini after-updates that they did? There were like five of those, they were likely tweaking those drops in response to a huge surge of farmers.

Whaddaya bet that Anet got a little shock when about a third of the population of GW suddenly came puring out of Deldrimor War Camp and started farming bosses?
Well if Anet were surprised by what happened then they certainly should not have been, what did they think was going to happen ? Especially given the cost of the keys compared to what you actually get from the chests. I've just been killing everything i can see just to get a key drop. In about an hours exploring i got that green water staff and a guildie (rest were henchies) picked up the stinger - I thought that was not too bad a return.