pommel of 20% vs. giants??

1 pages • Page 1
s
sphere830
Ascalonian Squire
• #1
Does this count against Ettins? What do giants actually consist of?
l
legless_the_elf
Frost Gate Guardian
• #2
List of Giants:
Hill Giant lvl 20
Sand Giant lvl 22
Summit Giant Herder lvl 13
Summit Beastmaster lvl 24
Tundra giant lvl 24

I got this info from my guide book and ettins were in a completely different catagorie...ETTINS so I do not know if giantslying works against ettins but for some reason i doubt it

hope this help

ps: you can always just test it
Apple
Apple
Desert Nomad
• #3
Ettins is trollslaying
s
sphere830
Ascalonian Squire
• #4
Thanks for the info, now to find a 20% troll slayer!!
dont feel no pain
dont feel no pain
Forge Runner
• #5
same ^^, woot!!!! my final thrusts on healing sigit does 144 dmg and with the +20% that makes it 172...... *jaw drops*
s
sledgeunderhill
Krytan Explorer
• #6
According to Guildwiki, Trolls and Ettins are sub-classes of Giants.

http://www.guildwiki.org/wiki/Ettin
http://www.guildwiki.org/wiki/Giant

I did some testing on the Giantslaying mod and found that it did NOT modify the damage.

http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...7&postcount=31

Given the performance of the Giantslaying mod, I highly doubt the Trollslaying mod will actually make a difference.

Still, if someone wishes to spend the money on a Trollslaying mod (expect to pay about 15k for a perfect sword), make your tests and post.
s
sphere830
Ascalonian Squire
• #7
Well it seems that we have not come up with an answer!! I farmed the ettins last night with two swords. One is a sundering sword of fortitude, 10/10 +25 and 15% enchanted customized +20%, and one perfect fire sword of giant slaying 15% enchanted customized. I got the exact same results from both swords. So what mod would work? Does anyone have a troll slaying mod that would part with it? My IGN is Balsk Bushbuff, Ill be on later tonight. Thanks
D
DaSwede
Academy Page
• #8
Check here, I did the research myself:

http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...575#post932575
Hello Kitty
Hello Kitty
Academy Page
• #9
I heard in another post that the Ogre Slaying Knife thing helps against Ettins.

Too bad the damage is super low...
D
DaSwede
Academy Page
• #10
If ogre slaying knife works... wait for assassin to kick some serious ass
s
sledgeunderhill
Krytan Explorer
• #11
Quote: Originally Posted by dont feel no pain
same ^^, woot!!!! my final thrusts on healing sigit does 144 dmg and with the +20% that makes it 172...... *jaw drops* When 100 blades double criticals on Heal Sig for my warrior, I'm getting 84 x 2. This is uncustomized. When customized, it should hit 200 damage total.

Confirm, you're using troll slaying mod/elemental damage?

Also, report your wild blow rather than something that's a variable. That skill always results in a critical hit. Screenshot would be best.
D
DaSwede
Academy Page
• #12
I, too, would like some proof that trollslaying works on ettin
R
Rhuobhe
Wilds Pathfinder
• #13
I have a 20% trollslaying mod, however it's for a staff. Just FYI if anyone is interested

I'm not going to apply it and try it, because I don't want to take the chance of not being able to salvage later.
s
sphere830
Ascalonian Squire
• #14
[QUOTE=Rhuobhe]I have a 20% trollslaying mod, however it's for a staff. Just FYI if anyone is interested

I was farming last night and procured an axe grip of trollslaying 18%, but Im looking for a sword component, if anyone has one, or is interested in this one, I will gladly pay for and conduct this expirament to evolve the science of ettin slaying. We have far to of those two-headed creatures in Tyria. My IGN is Balsk Bushbuff. Adios, see you out there.