Summoning stones and gold other gold sinks in GW
3 pages • Page 2
p
N
Quote:
|
No. There has been a market saturation, which left only the rarest items marketable at all.
|
You'll note that I did not speculate on a reason for deflation, only noted the fact that deflation is happening. That is because the reason it is happening does not matter, only the fact that it is happening. And why, if deflation is already happening, would you be insistent about implementing some new things that would make deflation happen even faster?
If you think market saturation is a problem, find a solution that addresses that problem. Don't try to apply a fix to an unrelated (or at least uncausative) issue and expect it to make the problem you just stated go away.
Quote:
|
Since we like font tags.
There is no over-inflation. Thus, GW has ENOUGH gold sinks. Irrelevant is the fact thatALL NPC traders/merchants are gold sinks. |
Now, you COULD say, "Then buy minis or rare weapons from players". However, those are not gold sinks: that is moving gold from one account to another.
Also, merchants are only gold sinks when you buy something from them. However, they generate much more gold than they remove from the game.
As the game gets older, there is going to be a need to do something about the gold floating in the economy. Otherwise, it becomes as worthless as exp. points!
Quote:
|
Sorry, I disagree. I have had over 500K (Usually float between 700-800K) for at least 2 years now. Whenever I get to around 800-900K, I buy 100 lockpicks, a new armor set, or give it to my wife for HER titles. Once I max my TH title, I won't buy near as many lockpicks.
Now, you COULD say, "Then buy minis or rare weapons from players". However, those are not gold sinks: that is moving gold from one account to another. Also, merchants are only gold sinks when you buy something from them. However, they generate much more gold than they remove from the game. As the game gets older, there is going to be a need to do something about the gold floating in the economy. Otherwise, it becomes as worthless as exp. points! |
I
Sorry, I'm not trying to solve ANYTHING. What the market is or isn't in is immaterial: Those are prices for items that players are buying/selling. The developers do not NEED to get involved in THAT market: it is entirely player-generated. Gold sinks are things the delelopers place in the game to REMOVE gold from the game. I'm not saying lack of gold sinks is a problem, per se. I AM saying it would be nice to have other things to spend the money ON.
A broken Lockpick disappears from the game yes, but most or all Lockpicks that r sold by players r dropped ones.
If i buy Lockpicks, gold changes player, doesnt disappear.
That u may break a lockpick is not relevant to that.
So, i am thinking buying lockpicks is NOT a gold sick.
(Unless u buy them in large quantities from the merchant....)
Wanted to mention, that i doubt (but correct me if wrong) that craftable summoning stones is really a gold sink.
Technically yes, BUT they cost 1k, 1 skill point and craft mats.
To me that does NOT look appealing, even after the summoning sickness decrease.
To make them more appealing and a gold sink, they should only have a gold requirement.
Obviously, the price should be high enough to be a usefull money sink, but also low enough to be appealing.
An idea for a money sink; not free costumes, but (other) ones that u can buy with ingame gold.
If i buy Lockpicks, gold changes player, doesnt disappear.
That u may break a lockpick is not relevant to that.
So, i am thinking buying lockpicks is NOT a gold sick.
(Unless u buy them in large quantities from the merchant....)
Wanted to mention, that i doubt (but correct me if wrong) that craftable summoning stones is really a gold sink.
Technically yes, BUT they cost 1k, 1 skill point and craft mats.
To me that does NOT look appealing, even after the summoning sickness decrease.
To make them more appealing and a gold sink, they should only have a gold requirement.
Obviously, the price should be high enough to be a usefull money sink, but also low enough to be appealing.
An idea for a money sink; not free costumes, but (other) ones that u can buy with ingame gold.
A
Quote:
|
There also seems to be a bit of a misunderstanding with material and other traders, who actually have their own stock that slowly recharges.
|
Um, nope. Sorry, but that's simply not true. Their stock comes from, and ONLY from, things that players sell to them. It does not "slowly recharge".
Quote:
|
A broken Lockpick disappears from the game yes, but most or all Lockpicks that r sold by players r dropped ones.
|
Which is exactly what is happening.
Quote:
|
A broken Lockpick disappears from the game yes, but most or all Lockpicks that r sold by players r dropped ones.
If i buy Lockpicks, gold changes player, doesnt disappear. That u may break a lockpick is not relevant to that. So, i am thinking buying lockpicks is NOT a gold sick. (Unless u buy them in large quantities from the merchant....) |
Just because you buy them from other players doesn't mean that everyone does.
For the most part Lockpicks ARE a goldsink.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Improvavel
Deflation of what?
Of things that aren't traded in gold/platinum? Of items that can keep being produced and there are more available with each day? |
Quote:
|
Sorry, I'm not trying to solve ANYTHING. What the market is or isn't in is immaterial: Those are prices for items that players are buying/selling. The developers do not NEED to get involved in THAT market: it is entirely player-generated. Gold sinks are things the delelopers place in the game to REMOVE gold from the game. I'm not saying lack of gold sinks is a problem, per se. I AM saying it would be nice to have other things to spend the money ON.
|
If you're just looking for more content (that's what I seem to be gathering), there are ways to do that that don't involve gold sinks.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Ailina
Um, nope. Sorry, but that's simply not true. Their stock comes from, and ONLY from, things that players sell to them. It does not "slowly recharge".
|
Do you actually have any calculations to support that thesis?
From my experience, prices do not go down so much as people simply see that what they have would be more of a hassle to sell to a player than to merchant and the result is that people simply don't sell things any more. Fewer and fewer items, or rather types of items, are offered for sale.
Also, we must remember to keep the relative value of gold in mind. We earn gold much more quickly these days due to the Zaishen, WiK bounties, Keiran missions and similar.
From my experience, prices do not go down so much as people simply see that what they have would be more of a hassle to sell to a player than to merchant and the result is that people simply don't sell things any more. Fewer and fewer items, or rather types of items, are offered for sale.
Also, we must remember to keep the relative value of gold in mind. We earn gold much more quickly these days due to the Zaishen, WiK bounties, Keiran missions and similar.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Iuris
Do you actually have any calculations to support that thesis?
|
4 months ago: armbrace ask attempts at 23e
Now: Attempts between 21e and 20e
4 months ago: Ecto sales hovering around 7.5k for one (easy to both buy and sell that), 13/100k.
1 month ago: Easy to buy 14/100k.
Now: Easy to buy down below 7k.
(Don't expect the < 7k price to stick, this is probably due to a sudden flood of ecto supply thanks to the past two weeks of events).
Alcohol/Sweets: No appreciable change as far as I can tell.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Iuris
From my experience, prices do not go down so much as people simply see that what they have would be more of a hassle to sell to a player than to merchant and the result is that people simply don't sell things any more. Fewer and fewer items, or rather types of items, are offered for sale.
|

