First of all I think Guild Wars is a brilliant game idea, story, world etc. This bit of whine is probably more about GW2 wishing anyway.
Have the option to map travel into areas which are already vanquished/visited
I have no patience for running through areas again and again, while all my heroes and henchmen die during the running only to have DP in the next area. There's supposed to be minimal grinding in this game, and clearing the same areas over and over doesn't indicate that. The spawn point could be at the end of the map that you have traveled past. Say I've walked Black Curtain and Talmark Wilderness to Majesty's Rest, perhaps I could now map travel to that side of Majesty's Rest.
Collector items like eyes, tusks etc. should come 1 per corpse
Again I have no patience to kill 50 monsters in an area far away, re-entering the map to kill more, just to get some tusks or jaws so I can collect a weapon for some build testing. I should simply be able to kill, say 4 trolls to get 4 troll tusks, get the weapon and move on.
The prices of everything are ridiculous
2500 for the small equipment pack. I don't know what the largest equipment pack costs in game gold, but it is 7500 Zaishen copper (I have 190 so far).These latest additions are quite crazy. But a lot of other stuff is crazy as well. Black dyes drop rarely and cost a lot. Shouldn't all the colors drop equally, and also, one would think soot is the most common color, but I guess I am wrong. Elite armors, great to have in game, never going to buy them, I suppose. My character is now carrying 17k and that's like maybe worth 1 piece in elite armor. Just getting the 5k for my standard armor was a stretch in its time, in Prophecies. Don't get me started on crafted weapons, I've never crafted one because of the 5k, 10k, 15k ridiculousness. Same goes for passage to FoW and others, too expensive in game gold. I've never seen a green or ecto drop outside of tombs and I'm not always in the mood for farming and grinding. You could halve the price of most anything and it would be good in relation to what you get from actual adventuring currently. Perhaps with some of my suggestions the prices would be reasonable in terms of time spent playing.
Crafted weapons are not crafted
You get the idea from the word crafting that you can influence what you are ordering. Shape, form, modifications. Mainly, the suffixes and prefixes of the weapon. Yet crafting is quite bland. It's just an overpriced shop for weapons that sometimes don't even have any mods, you have to find them yourself. That doesn't speed up or help me greatly to get the weapon I want for my build idea. Where are the real weaponsmiths who make what you need? In PvP you can just create the weapon from pieces, I'm looking for similar in PvE, but with of course some sensible in game price in gold and materials.
The monsters and the heroes are not in balance, same goes for PvE and PvP
There is no unified ruleset between PvE and PvP. PvE only skills indicate in their might, that you need more power in PvE. Why not unify the system to have all the same tactics available in PvE and PvP. To bring the builds together. Right now, not many are interested in e-denial in PvE because of the apparently colossal energy regeneration of monsters. Monsters also seem to have comparably ridiculous amounts of health, or health regeneration. Drop the regenerations, make the monsters play the same rules as players and heroes and as people do in PvP. In theory, a confronted humanoid should be in all respects as powerful as any PvP player, and also not over lvl 20. In fact, over lvl 20 monsters should always be vastly different, like dragons and wurms. Then you could also have species-specific regen rates, armor etc. The coded AI should be similar in henchmen and heroes as they are in the enemies. If enemies run from AoE, so should the heroes. Better yet, hero AI should be customizable.
Hero and henchmen AI need to be improved or customizable
Microing heroes in real time can be a bit difficult. I play a frontline warrior mainly and have no interest in babysitting my backrow casters. A large number of party wipes happen due to elementalists or other form of mass-damage inflicters. Usually a wurm siege or meteor shower. In the case of meteor shower and other damage over time area of effect spells, it would be good for the heroes and henchmen to just flee the area. A some sort of customize AI option should be made available in GW2. Some simple sliders and values and conditions that need be met for some action. Preferably also the AI of your own character should be customizable. For example having conditional skill use triggers such as when "Watch yourself!" is ready, shout it out. Then I could focus on the essential skills of interruption and stuff in my first few slots, instead of just "REMEMBER TO CLICK NUMBER 8 MAN!" There is also a need for hero/henchmen formations: spreading out, triangles, squares, circles, lines... etc. Also an option to attack move (kill everything from here to there), or move while continuing healing should be available. Currently, flagging troops while they are conditioned and hexed gets them killed with degen, yet unflagging stops them from fleeing and gets them killed as well.
There are few options to do at the end of a dungeon with -60 DP
To reduce the frustration of grinding same halls again because a quest or mission failed in a far away place, there could possibly be a way to summon help from guild members, or flag the place so the monsters do not respawn on next visit. Perhaps having portals in dungeons and far away places that transport you into an outpost, the next time you use that portal in the outpost, it would take you back to that dungeon and the same instance of it. Entering any other explorable area would clear the portal.
Time spent running around is too high
Noticeable is the size of structures, staircases and distances compared to the characters. The overall time spent running is quite long. Perhaps 4-8% faster might be better, but more likely having more outposts, aforementioned dungeon recall portals, and less grinding elements waiting for special drops etc. might be more fashionable ways to reduce time spent just running to places.
/bonus is too powerful and not available to all
Some of the /bonus weapons are a bit too powerful, such as Hourglass Staff. The whole ability to just create new items from nothing, indefinitely, with near perfect stats, is ridiculous, because this makes ones heroes much more capable that what others have available, for much less effort. It shouldn't be too effective, if it is not available to all players equally. Fair play should stay away from things that are unlimited and privileged.
Indefinitely spawning enemies break immersion
Have no thing in infinite supply. And if you have infinite enemies, do not make them not yield any experience or loot. The point in question is a certain golem related mission where unlimited golems spawn giving no gold or loot and possibly no experience either. Just because they are infinite shouldn't change the loot. Also, if the golems are infinite, it breaks story, because infinite golems should be able to deal with any "destroyer threat" all by itself. Few things are infinite, those are usually arrows and spears for gameplay's sake, keep it that way. Fix would be that the golems simply cease spawning after a counter hits a limit.
There are no adventure skills
But, I've read about swimming coming to GW2. What I am actually referring to is passive, always available certain small abilities such as: wetting yourself in a pond to remove burning and gain a short-term immunity to burning. Or perhaps class-specific secondary skills: for example rangers could have a passive skill related to wilderness survival that shows pop-up or pop-down creatures in the radar. What sort of ranger can't track and see traps?
Don't have automated turrets that are indestructable
A "nothing too noticeable should be indestructable or infinite"-case, or nothing that can attack at least. Maybe if the turrets ran out of ammo, then they would make sense as being indestructable. But having annoying non-targetable turrets spamming indefinitely is annoying to say the least. Luckily not all turrets are especially damaging, but an irritating detail nonetheless.
An obvious trap scenario should give an opportunity to strike first
There is this spot in a dungeon for example with multiple zombies or golems standing around being neutral. That's weird, and you just know that by going forward they will eventually attack while you are in the worst position possible. Anyone can see through these Hollywood scripts. The player should be able to attack them pre-emptively, if they are going to turn hostile later on.
What is with titles
Who the hell wants to do death leveling for weeks? Who wants to scrape maps? How is that interesting to anyone anymore? "Hey, let's jiggle the screen in this corner to get that 0.00000000000001% in cartography. Man, this is good gaming! Uh-huh?" If there are rewards for these titles in GW2, I hope they are not as lame as superb items inserted in /bonus i.e. overly powerful, unlimited in nature and ridiculous (let's give cartographers twice the running speed geez). It's of course only fair to recognize intensive players, but making it so that everyone should do these boring aspects of the game just to get some benefit is mega lame.
P


