Why is it that Ecto prices are so all important?
I have a serious issue with the way that SF farming has been nerfed. I could have understood if Anet said, "Well, it's too powerful," but instead the reason is the economy.
And why is that a bad thing? Because it was only done to protect the price of ectos. The price of Obs armour in money terms only changed by about 100k gold. Anet never said that the price of obsidian shards were unacceptable, even though it was 1.4k.
The fact that there is supply and demand also means that given time, the money that farmers made would also dwindle. When SF Chaos Plains farming came out, it was not impossible to make 54k in an hour. Just before the nerf, it had already dropped to ~36k (assuming one could farm 12 ectos over two runs in that hour, which is frankly a generous average). My point is that the farming would quickly reduce the prices of ectos to the point where other types of farming would be more appealing.
More importantly, Shard prices actually ROSE. What does this mean? It means that the demand for shards also rose. Ideally there should be no price disparity between shards and ectos, because they are both used in equal amount for Obs armour, and niether is particularly harder than the other to farm.
So the ONLY reason that Ectos were more valuable, is their use as currency. And the flooding of the market with ectos meant that once again, people could buy ectos for the purpose that they were originally intended for, i.e. to make obsidian armour. I don't think it's OK to protect a bunch of traders who've hoarded a certain type of item for the purpose of currency, especially when the use of that item for currency serves as an obstacle for the items original intended purpose.
So please stop messing with the economy. Guild Wars has been around for three years and you WILL start to see market saturation as new players dwindle and people start to wait for GW2. It's part of the natural lifespan of online games, and at best you will merely slow it down. Prestige items will indeed be common among older players, and it's unreasonable to expect that such items will remain "rare" indefinitely.
Anyone who agrees with this post may add their name to the thread.
E

