Suggestions for Guild wars or Guild wars 2

I had recently thought up some pretty neat ideas and I want someone to be as blunt honest about what they think of these ideas or tell me how these ideas could be improved.


1) "Town Exile" - I've noticed quite a bit when in town arguments break out of some sort and as we all know fighting isn't suppose to be allowed on the main lands against other humans. For those who want to fight they can but regardless of who wins the guards come and attack you until you die or leave. If you die to a guard or the other player you fought you are transfered to the explorable area and may not enter that town for like a hour or so.

2) "Shop Owning" - I feel that if we were able to purchase a sigial and take it to any main city/town we should beable to take it to someone in town and it would allow us to open our own shop. After the shop is opened it would onlycost you 100g to put any item you want up for auction or for sale. The item is handed to the shop and if no bids/buyers you may witdraw the item at anytime but again as long as there are no buyers or bidders.This would allow other players to buy your items even when your offline or away. You would check back at the shop to see if your item is sold or if its still there.

3) "Attack on the town" - Lets assume your standing in the middle of ascalon and 20 or so charr walk threw the gate. I feel you should be allowed to defend ascalon. I think this would make the game a bit more interesting.

4) "Halloween suggestion" - I enjoy the halloween festival the most and I also appeciate the release of the mini mad king thorn pet (I bought one :P) I think a elite "haunted House" should be added to the halloween festival or just a haunted house in general, maybe even a dungeon.

Get back to me let me know what you think and please you may be blunt honest of my ideas or help me fix them and make them better. I would defently like to see these ideas be put into action and I want to be more apart of the guild wars community.

First Reply... I feel special

Personally, I think that a Town Exile would be great. I could end up in that at some point ... however, would that not cause more tension?

The Auction/Shop sounds good, however, how do you give the person your item when your offfline? And, personally, it wouldn't give new players a chance to bid, because more exp'd people will know what to buy, and when to bid, at the right price.

My Favourite Idea of all, the Attack on the Town! 'd love to unleash hell with other players as some random charr walk into Ascalon I'd love to Ursan or Volfen a group of 20 Great Idea!

And the Halloween dungeon is an idea that we could see in the future

The item is placed in the shop it self if the player buys the item they get it the time they buy it. The seller returns to the shop for their gold. Thanks for your suggestions

1) Do scrimmages. Gw=/=PK.
2) No. With so many otuposts and districts, people will start sitting in districts, districts which would get filled with sitting ducks. Xunlai Marketplace is the Way to go.
3) Hello? This is GW. Outposts are non-attacks areas. They are outposts because you can't use the skills in your skill bar there. When attacking is needed in an outpost, they make an 'explorable copy'.

4) You mean an event mission? Phew. This suggestion is saved by that.
Event missions are good.
We have then in the Dragon Festival, and in Wintersday.
It would be good to have special missions in each festival event.

Canthan and Halloween have quests, but not missions.
Missions would be great.

First two ideas-I have to agree with Mithran. And I'm sure I've seen the first suggestion actualy implemented in another game somewhere.....

For number 3, not in GW1, but if you've read some of the GW2 literature, you'd know they have something similar to that in the works.

For number 4, yeah a Halloween dungeon would be sweet.

I would really love to see the Dev's NOT give up on GW1 while we enjoy GW2.
There could still be other campaigns (introducing new characters) every so often, and at the same time, we can enjoy the newness of GW2. I will never stop playing GW1, but I do want to play GW2 as well. This would keep both games fresh for those of us who would like to play both. Also, and i know this has been mentioned a gazillion and a half times, but barbershops, etc to give hairstyle options; etc. Things that would be added in game to lend to the diversity and freshness.

sounds like we will have your "attack on the town" suggestion in gw2.

the shop idea sounds fine, just put up the item and price, then collect your gold when someone buys it.

Btw, does anyone know when in 2009 GW2 will be released ? I hope there is a "preview" weekend we can all try out to see how we like it.

Just another thought while I'm rambling. How about when GW 2 comes out, there would be another GW1 campaign for those who want to play that. Couple new characters ( you can never have enough characters imo) Something to jazz up the first game while celebrating the new one.

I'm pretty sure something like this has already been announced for GW2, like, a year ago.

/agreed.
I like these, specially the "defend the town" one

well I appciate your advice and MithranArkanere I would like a few suggestion from you to help make these ideas a bit better then.

Suggestion 1 is too abusable.

This thread violates two rules:
A) don't post "a couple of idea" threads
B) Post GW2 suggestions go in the GW2 sticky http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...php?t=10214062

Thanks HawkofStorms,

Please don't post threads with multiple ideas, just start a thread for each one, just make sure we don't have threads already started about the same idea.

Also GW2 suggestions go in this thread here; http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...php?t=10214062