How do you feel about references?

3 pages Page 1
C
Crescent Sky
Academy Page
#1
Every so often you come across NPC names and Boss names and skills names and even inscriptions that are references to songs, people or pop culture stuff.
How do u feel about it?

Personally i despised it at first. It kinda took away that "fantasy" feeling away from the game for me knowing that Dupek The Mighty refers to Dupek, which sorta means Asshole in polish, Edinaz refers to Zidane, etc. I got over it :\
How about u guys?
A
A11Eur0
Furnace Stoker
#2
"I got over it."

Good call. It's a game, and it's made in the 21st century. If you want purist RPG, go play DnD. This is a fun game to play for casual players, not hardcore RP'ers.
Snow Bunny
Snow Bunny
Alcoholic From Yale
#3
Um, I find it hilarious.

GG?
Zinger314
Zinger314
Debbie Downer
#4
Guild Wars has an extremely disappointingly low amount of easter eggs compared to most other games. The only one I can remember is the Elaine Rigbey Easter Egg in Ascalon city...because that's the only one that I've seen that was cool.
A
A11Eur0
Furnace Stoker
#5
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zinger314
Guild Wars has an extremely disappointingly low amount of easter eggs compared to most other games. The only one I can remember is the Elaine Rigbey Easter Egg in Ascalon city...because that's the only one that I've seen that was cool.
What about it?
Bryant Again
Bryant Again
Hall Hero
#6
It bugs me, but Guild Wars never was terribly immersive. Let's hope it's a little better next time.
DarkWasp
DarkWasp
Desert Nomad
#7
Well the story presentation is nothing epic to boast about. So I like the humor in the names.

Maybe not if the game were more serious.
Bryant Again
Bryant Again
Hall Hero
#8
The main campaigns are serious (save for GW:EN, ungh), but everything else is just too humorous. It really gets to me sometimes.

If most of the quests and the like were written as good as Gwen's encounter with her mother, then I'd be playing through the games again and again.
arcanemacabre
arcanemacabre
Grotto Attendant
#9
Agree with Bryant. I like a few of them, they are amusing, but at the same time ruin any amount of role-playing immersion the game would otherwise have. I do hope that GW2 is more role-player friendly, and that these pop-culture references are kept at a minimum.
RhanoctJocosa
RhanoctJocosa
Legendary Korean
#10
I was very, very amused when I saw the bosses named after Ensign and JR. Some are pretty lame, though.

EDIT: the master and bloodlight chat between those two kids at the snowball arena was awesome.
C
Crescent Sky
Academy Page
#11
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bryant Again
The main campaigns are serious (save for GW:EN, ungh), but everything else is just too humorous. It really gets to me sometimes.

If most of the quests and the like were written as good as Gwen's encounter with her mother, then I'd be playing through the games again and again.
Yeah i think that's what did it for me. Got over it once i started seein loads of dinosaurs in GWEN and robot lookin golems (i know ppl explained how they are magic but they will always seem like poorly explained robots to me though). Then i couldn't take the game seriously if i wanted either way.
S
Saelis Scarfang
Academy Page
#13
Quote:
Originally Posted by RhanoctJocosa
I was very, very amused when I saw the bosses named after Ensign and JR. Some are pretty lame, though.

EDIT: the master and bloodlight chat between those two kids at the snowball arena was awesome.
I've found Ensign, but which one's named after JR my noobcake, cause I can't find it in the Wiki.
Neo Nugget
Neo Nugget
Site Contributor
#14
I likem, especially the skill references.
Curse You
Curse You
Furnace Stoker
#15
Well, since I wrote the Drakes on the Plain article for GuildWiki... I think I'll have to say I like them.
a
anonymous
Wilds Pathfinder
#16
I like them most of the time, some are pretty funny. I don't really play for immersion and I have a better time when I have a laugh.
Onarik Amrak
Onarik Amrak
Forge Runner
#17
I have no strong feelings for or against.
pamelf
pamelf
Forge Runner
#18
I think they're hilarious!
Kyrein
Kyrein
Krytan Explorer
#19
im fine with them
doesnt really bother me because i dont really care if the name of a boss is some sports persons name backwards
Longasc
Longasc
Forge Runner
#20
Too many references are cheap, they cannot replace a proper story and some ingenuity.

They are good as an addition for a laugh and I in general like them, but they need a proper world building to back them up, not even more references to pop culture.