R
To Heal or to Prot that is the question!
1 pages • Page 1
I wasn't even aware there was the question.
Prot > Heal
Hybrid > all
PUGs prefer heal
PUGs are clueless.
[skill]Reversal of fortune[/skill][skill]Shield of Absorption[/skill][skill]Word of Healing[/skill][skill]glyph of lesser energy[/skill][skill]protective spirit[/skill][skill]aegis[/skill][skill]dismiss condition[/skill][skill]cure hex[/skill]
or something simmilar.
Prot > Heal
Hybrid > all
PUGs prefer heal
PUGs are clueless.
[skill]Reversal of fortune[/skill][skill]Shield of Absorption[/skill][skill]Word of Healing[/skill][skill]glyph of lesser energy[/skill][skill]protective spirit[/skill][skill]aegis[/skill][skill]dismiss condition[/skill][skill]cure hex[/skill]
or something simmilar.
R
Do both, run a hyrbrid Prot/Heal bar (like the one posted above).
It's far more efficient than pure Heal and pure Prot - you do NOT need 8 slots to make red bars go up, you need WoH and Kiss at most.
Similarly, pure Prot is uneeded overkill for most of PvE.
However, PuGs scream for healing monks because they are, by and large, clueless scrubs.
Hybrid > PvE
It's far more efficient than pure Heal and pure Prot - you do NOT need 8 slots to make red bars go up, you need WoH and Kiss at most.
Similarly, pure Prot is uneeded overkill for most of PvE.
However, PuGs scream for healing monks because they are, by and large, clueless scrubs.
Hybrid > PvE
I get asked to swap my Prot build out for a Heal build all the time in PUGs. I've only agreed to do it twice, both today, and it was a double wipe.
I should have just turned down the PUG invite. Healing just can't keep up with Prot unless there's someone else there doing already.
A lot of people here will tell you Hybrid - and that's not bad advice, but I personally find I do best as pure Protection.
My usual build is something similar to:
[skill]Reversal of fortune[/skill][skill]guardian[/skill][skill]zealous benediction[/skill][skill]protective spirit[/skill][skill]draw conditions[/skill][skill]remove hex[/skill][skill]aegis[/skill][skill]rebirth[/skill]
Sometimes I swap out Guardian for;
[skill]Shield of Absorption[/skill]. Guardian is a weaker version of Aegis in some regards, but handy to spam whereas Aegis is handy as a pre-prot.
Remove Hex is the weakpoint in that build, and if I expect a hex heavy area I'll put something else in there.
I should have just turned down the PUG invite. Healing just can't keep up with Prot unless there's someone else there doing already.
A lot of people here will tell you Hybrid - and that's not bad advice, but I personally find I do best as pure Protection.
My usual build is something similar to:
[skill]Reversal of fortune[/skill][skill]guardian[/skill][skill]zealous benediction[/skill][skill]protective spirit[/skill][skill]draw conditions[/skill][skill]remove hex[/skill][skill]aegis[/skill][skill]rebirth[/skill]
Sometimes I swap out Guardian for;
[skill]Shield of Absorption[/skill]. Guardian is a weaker version of Aegis in some regards, but handy to spam whereas Aegis is handy as a pre-prot.
Remove Hex is the weakpoint in that build, and if I expect a hex heavy area I'll put something else in there.
A
W
epic! 
Quote:
Originally Posted by arcady
I get asked to swap my Prot build out for a Heal build all the time in PUGs.
I get the same thing, but you should be able to run either. Typically groups will need one healer and one prot unless you are in the lower level ares where the party size is 4-6 then the hybrid is the best. I ussualy take a similar build to Arcady, but will switch to a Healer's Boon build if I must go healing. Although most of the time I just use henchies, PUGing ussually fails in most of the PUGs I have been in.
It depends, either route you go you shouldn't have any problem getting consistent PUG's, but if you're just learning the art of Monking, it's *usually* better to start with Healing Prayers, and once you've learned the nuances of it, move to Protection. Protection is a lot harder to play, and even harder to master, but the people that have are nothing short of awe-inspiring. In the end it really boils down to personal preference I guess.
Quote:
which one do most groups want
There can be a huge difference between the needs of a (PUG) group and what they want.
Your team setup and your enemies determines if you go heal or prot.
In general, hybrid builds as surgested above, will do the job.
However, do not argue in PUGs on healing/protting, unless you can tell them why your build fits better in the team + mission/quest than the surgested build.
Your team setup and your enemies determines if you go heal or prot.
In general, hybrid builds as surgested above, will do the job.
However, do not argue in PUGs on healing/protting, unless you can tell them why your build fits better in the team + mission/quest than the surgested build.
S
M
Quote:
Originally Posted by the_jos
There can be a huge difference between the needs of a (PUG) group and what they want.
Your team setup and your enemies determines if you go heal or prot.
In general, hybrid builds as surgested above, will do the job.
However, do not argue in PUGs on healing/protting, unless you can tell them why your build fits better in the team + mission/quest than the surgested build. I totally agree. If you can intelligently and calmly explain why one way is better than the other then you have a greater chance of playing the way you want. Just don't try to do this by insulting someone or being arrogant.
If the team insists on a certain way then you have 2 choices. Their way or the highway.
Your team setup and your enemies determines if you go heal or prot.
In general, hybrid builds as surgested above, will do the job.
However, do not argue in PUGs on healing/protting, unless you can tell them why your build fits better in the team + mission/quest than the surgested build. I totally agree. If you can intelligently and calmly explain why one way is better than the other then you have a greater chance of playing the way you want. Just don't try to do this by insulting someone or being arrogant.
If the team insists on a certain way then you have 2 choices. Their way or the highway.
T
- Hybrids work well
- Pre-protting > healing. Observe the battlefield and anticipate.
- Infusing is a good skill to learn.
I strongly discourage you from running "a nice build that is pretty much balanced and will generally be used throughout my monk's career" all the time. Try different builds and try to understand why some builds work, while others fail.
- Pre-protting > healing. Observe the battlefield and anticipate.
- Infusing is a good skill to learn.
I strongly discourage you from running "a nice build that is pretty much balanced and will generally be used throughout my monk's career" all the time. Try different builds and try to understand why some builds work, while others fail.
yo what i like to do is hero it with 3 hero monks (dunk tahlk oggy)
make em all mo/me, put mantra of inscriptions on each of them, sig of judgement on 2, bane sig on 3, castigation sig on 3, expel hexes on one, rest of their bar consists of a hybrid heal, smite support.
i.e. reversal of dmg, smite hex, smite condition, sig of devotion, etc etc.
while i myself am probably a healer's boon heal partyer blah blah.
;] i run weird stuff.
make em all mo/me, put mantra of inscriptions on each of them, sig of judgement on 2, bane sig on 3, castigation sig on 3, expel hexes on one, rest of their bar consists of a hybrid heal, smite support.
i.e. reversal of dmg, smite hex, smite condition, sig of devotion, etc etc.
while i myself am probably a healer's boon heal partyer blah blah.
;] i run weird stuff.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Celestial_Kitsune
- Hybrids work well
- Pre-protting > healing. Observe the battlefield and anticipate.
- Infusing is a good skill to learn.
I strongly discourage you from running "a nice build that is pretty much balanced and will generally be used throughout my monk's career" all the time. Try different builds and try to understand why some builds work, while others fail. QFT
Celestial pretty much summed it up
- Pre-protting > healing. Observe the battlefield and anticipate.
- Infusing is a good skill to learn.
I strongly discourage you from running "a nice build that is pretty much balanced and will generally be used throughout my monk's career" all the time. Try different builds and try to understand why some builds work, while others fail. QFT
Celestial pretty much summed it up