|
Originally Posted by Burst Cancel
As I stated above, GW allows you to pick your tools. Therefore, in order to be difficult, the game must, to some degree, force you to pick the better tools. This degree is largely what determines difficulty in GW PvE. Again, not all skills and combinations are equally good. Therefore, if an area can be beaten using sub-optimal skills, it must, by definition, be easy when using optimal skills. A large part of GW is considering what the enemy is using, and bringing skills to account for that. Even so, there is some variation. For instance, in dealing with boss elementalists you can succeed in two main ways: 1) interrupts or 2) damage reduction. The game doesn't force you to take one over the other, but it does require you to compensate for the enemy's overpowered damage in some way.
Basically, by asking for build diversity, you are asking for the game to be made easier. Given that a large number of players (at least, the ones that frequent forums) already find the game unacceptably easy, I don't see any reason to do that. Rather, those who are having trouble should either improve their level of play, or stick to areas that they can beat.
Build diversity doesn't necessarily mean an easier game. Whenever a subject like this comes up, take a look at the responses. The vast majority sit in two camps - one agrees that many parts of the game are simply overpowered and frustrating to the normal, casual player. The other camp finds all areas of the game far too easy. Only a small minority actually find a decent challange throughout. I had the exact same experience with Factions. Once leaving the island, I though the entire mainland was way too overpowered, and the leap of difficulty from Shing Jea to Kaineng was too large to properly prepare a newer player for the challenge. However, once Heroes came about, I basically breezed through the entire campaign with my D/A. That tells me something is wrong here. The way to fix this dicotemy is to remove the dependance of making higher level mobs tougher by giving them higher Offensive capabilities, and using larger numbers to artificially increase the difficulty level of the area.
As you say above, the current system forces you into making certain selections as you reach the higher levels of the game. Using the David and Goliath example, in GW David would never be able to defeat Goliath. The only way to bring Goliath down would be with another Cyclops who has a larger club, and perhaps some form of shield to help ward off some of Goliath's damage dealing. It's really too late to adjust GW's combat with a major overhaul, but what I am looking for in GW2 is a way to give David a shot at Goliath without making him a pushover for another cyclops. We need to take away the reliance of Goliath's ability to do 500+ damage with each blow, and make him a tougher defensive character. This way, in a new combat system, even a weaker party has a chance to bring him down as long as they work together as a team and use the good tactics.
We already have bits and pieces of the total system I would like to see in place - the natural abilities of Bosses such as their Health regeneration and reduced hex/condition time. These are great defensive capabilites that are far too underpowered in my opinion, and variations should be used for every monster in the game. Monster specific skills - I am glad to see more of these in EotN, but still would like to see more reliance on these skills rather than mobs using common skills. Naturally, bosses would still need to carry elites for us to cap unless another system was implemented for their acquisition. The various Blessings and Title enhancements are also part of this new system I would like to have, but let's make more of them dependant on the tactics and skill choices of each party member.
Let's take a Warrior and an Assassin as examples. Assassin's have built in skill chains as a part of their profession - the Lead, Off Hand, and Dual Attacks. Warrior's can equate this chain by say using Hammer Bash with Crushing Blow, or beginner's sword skills Sever Artery, Gash, and Final Thrust. Nice attack chains using your primary profession and attribute, and able to a nice moderate amount of damage/degen. This would the the base for the new system. Now, Let's say we have the good ole W/Mo. Let's give him Bane Sig or Sig of Judgement with Crushing Blow. Now we have someone making use of his secondary prof and combining it with his primary prof skills. There should be a little extra bonus for this in damage for this chain. The same for the Assassin - instead of using a typical skill chain, he makes a chain of attacks using both is prime and secondary profession skills - he gets a bonus or a buff for being more creative with his attacks.
Now let's say that Warrior uses Sig of Judgement against a foe, then follows up with Crushing Blow, then a teammate of his comes in with a skill that is usable against a foe with Deep Wound. Not only does the Warrior make use of both his professions, but he has essentially set up a possible new chain of attacks for a second character - this should offer even bigger bonuses for the characters and party.
Essentially, the game would be rewarding a great working party just as it does now, but even a weaker party would still stand a chance when using proper tactics and skill chains - it would just take longer for them to take down their foe than the party who makes multiple and multi-character chains of attack. So let's take an end-dungeon boss, and reduce his devastating offensive capabilities, but really buff up defensive and inherent abilities, making him damn near impossible to kill. Without using attack chains or buffs, or what have you, it should be a stale mate between the party and the boss, niether one having the advantage nor being able to kill the other. However, the weaker party comes in using individual chains of attacks, dealing slightly more damage and giving themselves slightly more defensive buffs. They keep this up, and in the long run end up taking down the boss. Now bring in that powered up party - even with high damaging skills, they don't have an advantage over this boss unless they begin to work together to set up chains of attack among themselves. The first chain would eliminate the boss' natural healing ability, the second chain would eliminate a defensive spell, the next chain would take a major chunk of health from the boss, and so on and so forth. Not only would this party be getting bigger rewards, it would make combat a lot more than just call target and afk until the battle is won. The party would have to continue to make great skill chains to counter the boss' defensive capabilities.
Hanok Odbrook
Real Millennium Group Guild
Truth * Knowledge * Peace |