Items with % to fast recharge/cast spells add "luck" to pvp?

1 pages • Page 1
a
atreyu83
Ascalonian Squire
• #1
I havent seen this subject discussed anywhere and this issue had just occured to me.

Does it seem right that in some situations the winner of a pvp match might be decided by a Spell randomly hapening to Fast recharge due to fast recharge equipment? Two evenly matched teams and the victor being decided by a random number generator?

Or does equipment with % to fast cast/rechage have only an insignificant impact on matches to where it could never truly impact the eventual winner?

It would seem to me that this game mechanic adds an unneccesary element of luck to pvp in a game that strives soo much to be balanced. One does not have to stretch there imagination to think of some rare instances where a key spell fast recharging multiple times a row directly caused a team to win.

Am i making a big deal out of nothing?
ss1986v2
ss1986v2
Wilds Pathfinder
• #2
big deal out of nothing...
L
Lets Get to Healing
Banned
• #3
Quote:
Originally Posted by ss1986v2
big deal out of nothing...
/agree, this is NOT KoaBD.
Pwny Ride
Pwny Ride
Wilds Pathfinder
• #4
well then lets get rid of all staff, and focus, andshield and sword and ALL weapon bonuses.

Hey that ele has more energy than a wammo, lets make max nrg to 20, and while your at it, make all skills do 1 dmg.

Is this the 'balanced' that your looking for?
d
dgb
Jungle Guide
• #5
Everyone I know who uses those things factors them into average calculations and for instance a 25 minute GVG is easily enough for it to revert to the mean.

It's a non-event.
MadOnion
MadOnion
Lion's Arch Merchant
• #6
As the above poster has stated, the amount of times the extra bonus will occur per match, per team will end out roughly the same and is not worth worrying about.
Skuld
Skuld
Furnace Stoker
• #7
By taking the recharge/cast gear, you're missing out on +5 armour mods, +30 health ones etc. An extra cast of something is hardly going to win you the match, but that extra 30hp could save you from a spike, which possibly could.
FelixCarter
FelixCarter
Wilds Pathfinder
• #8
To the Op: I thought about it when I first did PvP, but it's such a small thing that it doesn't really affect the outcome of the battle too much. While their skill might recharge faster, they are still limited to their energy.

To everyone else: What is up with responding to forum questions by acting like the Op is retarded and has no right to breath anymore? It seems this forum becomes less friendly everyday...
Why don't we respond to newcomers by banning their asses? That'll teach them to ask questions. ¬_¬
arcanemacabre
arcanemacabre
Grotto Attendant
• #9
There already is a lot of luck involved in PvP with the Rock/Paper/Scissors style the skills have. Every build has a counter, and luck determines if you face that counter or not.
d
dgb
Jungle Guide
• #10
Quote:
Originally Posted by Skuld
By taking the recharge/cast gear, you're missing out on +5 armour mods, +30 health ones etc. An extra cast of something is hardly going to win you the match, but that extra 30hp could save you from a spike, which possibly could.
In the current meta yeah - usually you want them for things you calculate out at per second and want to cast them as soon as they come up. Boon-prot elite e-management, searing flames etc. all are very useful because they provide a direct increase in your flow be it damage or energy. More precision weapons like the things mesmers tend to use, while it being useful to have a fast recharge sometimes don't benefit to the same level.
Njaiguni Blaze
Njaiguni Blaze
Wilds Pathfinder
• #11
Everyone can have the same chance of skill recharge, armor penetration, attribute +1, tec. Therefore it's balanced.
Avarre
Avarre
Bubblegum Patrol
• #12
Quote:
Originally Posted by FelixCarter
Why don't we respond to newcomers by banning their asses? That'll teach them to ask questions. ¬_¬
Don't tempt me.

Flame posts cleared out, regardless of who is right or wrong, do not drag a thread off topic with accusations.
zwei2stein
zwei2stein
Grotto Attendant
• #13
Quote:
Originally Posted by Njaiguni Blaze
Everyone can have the same chance of skill recharge, armor penetration, attribute +1, tec. Therefore it's balanced.
actually no:

Rangers have +1/20% only for bows, same as Assassins and Dervishes for daggers and scythes respectivelly. Paragons cant have +1/20% for leadership.

Theese attributes also lack ANY linked items, thus Dervish and Assassin lines with spells do not have 20% attribute specific recharge/hct equipment possible, making their hrs max out at 20% (if staff) or 10% (want+focus) and hct at 10% regardless.

Theese things puts weaponless dervishes/assassins (they DO have interesting builds) at equipment disadvatage and making em join trapper rangers at using staves whose reqs they can not meet.
k
keli
Krytan Explorer
• #14
Quote:
Originally Posted by zwei2stein
actually no:

Rangers have +1/20% only for bows, same as Assassins and Dervishes for daggers and scythes respectivelly. Paragons cant have +1/20% for leadership.

Theese attributes also lack ANY linked items, thus Dervish and Assassin lines with spells do not have 20% attribute specific recharge/hct equipment possible, making their hrs max out at 20% (if staff) or 10% (want+focus) and hct at 10% regardless.

Theese things puts weaponless dervishes/assassins (they DO have interesting builds) at equipment disadvatage and making em join trapper rangers at using staves whose reqs they can not meet.
Warrior,ranger,dervish,paragon.. has got the chanhe of critical hit as the caster has got the chance of recharge and faster casting. In pvp, if a team better than the other the random generator doesnt mean anything. This system is well balanced (skills arent but anet is working to make it balanced).
Njaiguni Blaze
Njaiguni Blaze
Wilds Pathfinder
• #15
Quote:
Originally Posted by zwei2stein
actually no:

Rangers have +1/20% only for bows, same as Assassins and Dervishes for daggers and scythes respectivelly. Paragons cant have +1/20% for leadership.

Theese attributes also lack ANY linked items, thus Dervish and Assassin lines with spells do not have 20% attribute specific recharge/hct equipment possible, making their hrs max out at 20% (if staff) or 10% (want+focus) and hct at 10% regardless.

Theese things puts weaponless dervishes/assassins (they DO have interesting builds) at equipment disadvatage and making em join trapper rangers at using staves whose reqs they can not meet.
You misunderstood or I wasn't clear enough.
Lemme put it this way: Every warrior can have the same chance of swordsmanship +1 etc etc. Every Dervish can have the same chance of halving skill recharges of spells etc etc. Every monk can have the same chance of halving casting times of spells etc etc. Therefore it IS balanced. Don't compare a Warrior to a Monk please. That is not the "question" here.

BTW, if a person doesn't meet a req of a staff, he can't do the 11-22 dmg. Whooptidoo, as if that matters.
L
Lucky_
Ascalonian Squire
• #16
Every time attacker does damage with a non-candy cane item, he rolls a dice for luck. Dervishes have it worst, 9-41 damage distribution. So yes, luck always was, is, and will be a factor. In some cases, a major factor.
Skye Marin
Skye Marin
Jungle Guide
• #17
While spells have X% for casting time and recharge, weapon attacks and weapon skills have X% chance of a critical hit, or doing any damage on their range.

A little bit of luck can go a ways, but I enjoy manipulating my luck with Mantra of Recovery and "Go For the Eyes!".
Savio
Savio
Teenager with attitude
• #18
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lucky_
Dervishes have it worst, 9-41 damage distribution.
Dervishes have it best with critical hit percentages.

Block/evade stances, Blind, critical hits... yes, they add an element of luck. But you're never going to be able to win a match purely on that luck.
Bankai
Bankai
Desert Nomad
• #19
A game without luck would be horrible.

If you want a game without luck, play the dragon arena when it's up again. Some time. Hopefully.
A
Antheus
Forge Runner
• #20
Chess could be considered a game without luck factor.

But what if your opponent misses a move that would lead to a 5 move win? Did you get lucky? Or are you more skilled? If the opponent were given enough time, they might see that move as well - but chess is a timed game.

All weapons depend on "luck" - namely the damage roll. The damage you take depends on roll of which armor piece gets hit. Recharge modifiers are the same - they might trigger, they might not. Probably half or mroe attacks depend on conditions or hexes. Chance to miss, evade, block, ...

What about getting that lucky diversion that applies just 0.1 second before target finishes casting? Or the lucky interrupt of 1/4 second spell? Is this luck or skill? Since it's impossible to interrupt 1/4 second spells by skill, then it has to be luck. Does that mean those skills should be made uninterruptible?

The very nature of our universe is based on chance. In the end the only thing that matters, are statistical odds. And as soon as you get into that perspective, there advantage given to you by "luck" can be extremly precisely determined.

But the key factor is, you cannot count on luck.