Jan 07, 2007, 10:59 AM // 10:59
|
#41
|
Krytan Explorer
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: sh*tvill england
Guild: tgc
Profession: Mo/
|
ok i have jsut borrowed this for another post ( im very sorry jesh, if u dont want this here jsut tell me ill remove it.)
***ALSO THIS IS IMPORTANT, I TAKE NO CREDIT FOR THE FOLLOWING TEXT, THIS HAS ALL COME FORM ANOTHER POST WITH SOME ONE MORE CLEVERER THAN ME POSTING IT. I JSUT BELIVE THAT IT WOUDL BENIFIT Xeones The Great, HERE AS HE COULD BE LES LIKELY TO READ IT ELSE WHERE, AL CRED IT SHOULD GO TO JESH NOT ME, THANK YOU*** ( have to make that clear :P)
Quote:
Originally Posted by jesh
Light of Deliverance at 16 Healing Prayers heals for a maximum of 85*8= 680hp for 5 energy, which equates to 136hp per energy - very nice! The condition on Light of Deliverance, is of course, the party member has to be below 80% hp. Compare this to Word Of Healing - max of 84+106= 190hp for 5 energy, which equals 38 hp per energy. Notice that this is the same energy efficiency reached by healing only 1 other ally with Heal Area.
The conditions to reach large numbers with Light of Deliverance/Heal Area/Heal Party are also much easier to reach than with Word of Healing. Letting a target get to 50%hp often means they're already dead.
|
so this to me makes it look like LoD s bettetr than WoH, per heal per energy
(again im sorry jesh, if u dissapore jsut tell me and ill remove it :P, i jsut belive he'll benafit form, it here)
|
|
|
Jan 07, 2007, 05:07 PM // 17:07
|
#42
|
Desert Nomad
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Domain of Broken Game Mechanics
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by olly123
take what every one has said with a pinch of salt, because its manyly prefrences.
|
People need to stop saying that skill choice is 'player preference', because it usually isn't, and it definitely isn't in this case. You can argue definitively that for a given situation, spell X is better than spell Y, period. Consider the environment, run the numbers, and you get a solid answer.
For instance, LoD is nice in PvE because damage tends to be moderate and distributed. The 80% condition limits its efficiency somewhat, but LoD still beats many other elites even in non-optimal situations simply because its potential efficiency is so enormously high to begin with. The situation changes if you have a good team that can manage aggro. With such a team, you can reasonably expect that most of the damage will be concentrated on the tank. LoD is far less attractive here because you'll rarely get more than 75 out of it.
|
|
|
Jan 07, 2007, 08:00 PM // 20:00
|
#43
|
Grindin'
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: MO
Profession: E/Mo
|
Lod on an otherwise traditional prot monk bar is hot.
|
|
|
Jan 07, 2007, 09:45 PM // 21:45
|
#44
|
Banned
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: American District 1
Guild: NDR|||We are recruiting|||PM me
|
again, LoD is out of question, because its a very little heal. personally, i dont give a crap about 680 total health healed. as burst said, if aggro is managed correctly, damage will usually focus on one person in pve. IMHO, LoD may be one of the worst heal elites out there, next to HH. consider this: what if one person is at 60% health, everyone else is near full. what a waste of an elite!!! also, i believe that even if damage is distributed, its just, imo, stupid to just spam a skill for every1 to gain hp. also, im going heal definitely, so ZB is out of question. so far, i havent been convinced that Word of Healing is not the most energy efficient healing elite out there. thanks.
|
|
|
Jan 07, 2007, 10:00 PM // 22:00
|
#45
|
Frost Gate Guardian
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Canada, Ottawa
Profession: Mo/
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xeones The Great
again, LoD is out of question, because its a very little heal. personally, i dont give a crap about 680 total health healed. as burst said, if aggro is managed correctly, damage will usually focus on one person in pve. IMHO, LoD may be one of the worst heal elites out there, next to HH. consider this: what if one person is at 60% health, everyone else is near full. what a waste of an elite!!! also, i believe that even if damage is distributed, its just, imo, stupid to just spam a skill for every1 to gain hp. also, im going heal definitely, so ZB is out of question. so far, i havent been convinced that Word of Healing is not the most energy efficient healing elite out there. thanks.
|
it's pve. You need to be ready to play with utter nuts. (although i guess you could say the same about pug pvp.)
LoD and Heal Party are the two best skills in the healing prayers line imo. A prot monk has to work to keep up with party-wide pressure most of the time, yet excels at the protection and healing of individual targets. PvE groups in the harder areas appear to be bringing a prot monk and a heal monk because party-wide healing is one of the only thing healers can do that prot monks can't. I love LoD in PvE. But this is just a suggestion sort of post, just trying my best to enlighten you
WoH is very outdated now, even glimmer of light overshadows that thing.
They way i see it is that LoD is to Heal Party what WoH is to Heal Other... except... even more efficient.
So, my suggestion for a build would either be a Mo/E ZB prot monk with Glyph of Lesser Energy, an LoD healer, or an HB Healer (with glyph heal party)
P.S. somebody feel free to tell me if my guesses about "top-level" pve monking is garbage. i havn't actually been into that new area at all yet.
Last edited by ubard; Jan 07, 2007 at 10:05 PM // 22:05..
|
|
|
Jan 07, 2007, 11:30 PM // 23:30
|
#46
|
Lion's Arch Merchant
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: RA, reporting you
|
Quote:
if aggro is managed correctly, damage will usually focus on one person in pve.
|
That is true. When it happens, and it's a joy to watch when it does, you can get by with casting healing breeze every 15 or 20 seconds. But the rest of the time, you need better spells.
Word of Healing isn't that bad. It used to be the best heal in the game, and everybody used it. If you want to use it, then use it. But take heal party, too, and things like dwayna's kiss and healing whisper. I think you'll change your mind.
The rest of us played through the game with the choice of our 2 elites, no glyph of lesser energy, and pugs. You kids have no idea how lucky you are.
For example, in that other thread about the river of flame, you have people running through lava, standing in lava and running away from the monsters. Now the warrior tries to tank, but the monsters are casters, and if you can hit them, they can hit you. So people are getting hit by fireballs, meteors, set on fire, attacked by little titans that suddenly appear, etc.
You're going to be spamming heal party non-stop, and it'll make you cry.
Last edited by martialis; Jan 07, 2007 at 11:46 PM // 23:46..
|
|
|
Jan 07, 2007, 11:32 PM // 23:32
|
#47
|
Banned
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: American District 1
Guild: NDR|||We are recruiting|||PM me
|
what i think is that LoD can be equally or even greaterly copied by glyph of lesser energy and heal party. word of healing heals for 228 health for allies under 50% and 122 for allies not under 50%. glimmer heals for 127 no matter what with a shorter recharge and charge. woh>glimmer>LoD
imo, orison isnt that bad, 101 health with 2 second recharge and for 5 energy. dont even try to lead to that singlepost about how horrible orison is, becuz it makes 0 sense.
woh
dwaynas kiss/mend condition
sig devotion
heal touch
orison
glyph of lesser energy
heal party
rebirth
glyph+heal party = some sort of LoD
orison = some sort of glimmer
woh cant really be matched, best way to repair extreme spikes, 228/122 hp every 4.75 seconds is unmatched.
this is the way its gonna be. period.
|
|
|
Jan 07, 2007, 11:32 PM // 23:32
|
#48
|
Jungle Guide
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Illinois, US
Guild: Heroes of Talia [HoT]
Profession: Mo/
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xeones
again, LoD is out of question, because its a very little heal.
|
A little heal on multiple players ends up being a big heal, and for 5 energy. 75hp is even that small of a heal to begin with. Glimmer only heals for 81hp, and that's single target. Party-wide healing is a big thing. Why do you think most GvG teams have a Heal Party E/Mo? You can get great mileage out of it, and the E/Mo will generally only have ~10 Healing. Isn't bad by any means.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xeones
as burst said, if aggro is managed correctly, damage will usually focus on one person in pve. IMHO, LoD may be one of the worst heal elites out there, next to HH.
|
Tanking is not what it once was, but this statement doesn't really make sense. If one person is always holding aggro, how is Healing Hands the worst elite? Healing Hands/Seed excel when one person is taking heavy aggro. HH and LoD work to counter purposes, and each is useful under the right circumstances. The "right circumstances" for HH usually means solo farming or, previously, gear tanking.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xeones
what if one person is at 60% health, everyone else is near full. what a waste of an elite!!!
|
You have 7 other skills on your bar, right? If only one person is hurt, the obvious solution is to use a single target heal. That doesn't make LoD any less valuable when multiple players are taking damage.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xeones
also, i believe that even if damage is distributed, its just, imo, stupid to just spam a skill for every1 to gain hp.
|
What is this supposed to mean? Having one skill that can handle widespread pressure is somehow "stupid?" What would be the "smart" thing to do in that situation? Single target heals? :?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xeones
also, im going heal definitely, so ZB is out of question
|
If you're deadset on the pure healing route, you'll only progress so far as a monk. It's ok as a way to learn the ropes, but I think you'll like prot better once you get a little more perspective.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xeones
so far, i havent been convinced that Word of Healing is not the most energy efficient healing elite out there.
|
WoH is efficient, but it's just not the best option generally. ZB is more efficient for single target healing. Glimmer is better for dealing with sticky situations (like when someone is below 50%hp and taking heavy fire). LoD is better for widespread damage. HH is better if you're somehow controlling aggro completely and only one person is ever being hit. WoH is a general application skill, but it doesn't excel at anything.
|
|
|
Jan 07, 2007, 11:40 PM // 23:40
|
#49
|
Jungle Guide
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: UK
Profession: W/
|
Why argue with a wammo ? X_x
|
|
|
Jan 08, 2007, 07:02 PM // 19:02
|
#50
|
Ascalonian Squire
Join Date: May 2006
Location: New Hampshire
Guild: Mages Elite [MAGE]
Profession: Mo/
|
I really think it all depends on the player.
A good monk should be able to efficiently keep the team members alive even with a "bad" build.
However, there are plenty of times I've seen a monk with a great build screw up.
There are definitely more efficient elites out there, but it depends on the player's style.
Reading through the posts, I've come to realize, my basic healing build is actually pretty bad...
I used:
Breeze, Orison, Dwayna's Kiss, WoH, Touch, Dismiss, Smite hex and rebirth
as my standard healing build and so far it has worked out pretty nicely.
But, after reading through the posts, I feel that my build could be even more efficient.
|
|
|
Jan 08, 2007, 07:49 PM // 19:49
|
#51
|
Forge Runner
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Thornill, ON, Canada
Guild: THE CANUCK MONKS (TCM)
Profession: W/R
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xeones The Great
what i think is that LoD can be equally or even greaterly copied by glyph of lesser energy and heal party. word of healing heals for 228 health for allies under 50% and 122 for allies not under 50%. glimmer heals for 127 no matter what with a shorter recharge and charge. woh>glimmer>LoD
imo, orison isnt that bad, 101 health with 2 second recharge and for 5 energy. dont even try to lead to that singlepost about how horrible orison is, becuz it makes 0 sense.
woh
dwaynas kiss/mend condition
sig devotion
heal touch
orison
glyph of lesser energy
heal party
rebirth
glyph+heal party = some sort of LoD
orison = some sort of glimmer
woh cant really be matched, best way to repair extreme spikes, 228/122 hp every 4.75 seconds is unmatched.
this is the way its gonna be. period.
|
If you are in Hell's Precipice, drop heal touch and get Extinguish. Don't use Mend Condition, get Mend Ailment (as you'll suffer from imps burning too).
Basically, keep Dwayna's Kiss and drop Healing Touch and get Extinguish. This will help you a lot in HP. The rest is fine.
|
|
|
Jan 08, 2007, 08:52 PM // 20:52
|
#52
|
Banned
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: American District 1
Guild: NDR|||We are recruiting|||PM me
|
@legendary ultimatum: stop being a wise-ass, seriously.
@effigy: i really cannot argue with you. anyways, u said heal party in GvG, but im PvE. so ur saying LoD is the way to go? and if
prot>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>h eal,
then why the hell did they even make healing an attribute? prot yay prot prot wtf? to everyone: if u play a heal monk, ur a ----ing retard. is that what ur trying to say? u really confuse me. T-T
@pick me: this build isnt only for hell's precipice, but thx anyways, and i always need touch for a 147 self-heal in 3/4 seconds. =]
@sunbear: uuhh, thanks?
|
|
|
Jan 08, 2007, 09:50 PM // 21:50
|
#53
|
Jungle Guide
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Illinois, US
Guild: Heroes of Talia [HoT]
Profession: Mo/
|
Healing is fine, but the point is it only heals. It's really not necessary to bring only heals when you have 8 skill slots. You could bring about 2-3 heals and then bring prot skills for the rest. Prot is good because it does a lot of things, including some healing. Pure healing is all right in easy areas, but the more damage you're facing the more important it is to keep that damage under control, which is what prot excels at. Point in case, try take a pure healer to Domain of Anguish and see how well it stands up. This is an extreme example, but it illustrates the point that preventing damage is usually better than trying to make up for it after the fact.
|
|
|
Jan 09, 2007, 09:16 AM // 09:16
|
#54
|
Jungle Guide
Join Date: Sep 2005
Profession: Mo/Me
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xeones The Great
@legendary ultimatum: stop being a wise-ass, seriously.
|
I dunno, the full guild hall scares me as well.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xeones The Great
and if
prot>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>h eal,
then why the hell did they even make healing an attribute? prot yay prot prot wtf? to everyone: if u play a heal monk, ur a ----ing retard. is that what ur trying to say? u really confuse me. T-T
|
Heal exists for heal party, it's elite version, gift of health, infuse health and maybe healing seed. Beyond that, the line is just retardedly stupid.
There are points for heal monks. They can pump out massive amounts of healing, it's true, but in nearly all circumstances prot monks splashing into healing for top ups will outperform heal monks. The conditions where heal monks are useful is when there you have a specialist prot monk, who does nothing else, as in cases like the old HA 8v8 backline. If you're not running a specialist prot monk, then run prots with splash into heal.
Generally pure heal monks are retarded, they have horrible bars, with five variations of orison, no heal party and no energy management. It's like the monk version of stance tanks. Utterly retarded but the pve crowd seems to like them.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xeones The Great
@pick me: this build isnt only for hell's precipice, but thx anyways, and i always need touch for a 147 self-heal in 3/4 seconds. =]
|
To throw your words back at you, if aggro is being managed, why do you need healing touch at all?
|
|
|
Jan 09, 2007, 02:42 PM // 14:42
|
#55
|
Academy Page
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Netherlands, The
Guild: Simple Life [Mbps]
Profession: Mo/
|
haha lovely discussion here
Skills are made to use, you can make a nice bar out of it, it is called non Gimmick
Healing Breeze? Why not? Give me 1 ****ing good reason why not? Cause you think ure better then the guy using it? Be happy that people use it, nearly makes u 1 of the best monks
Healing Breeze is a sort of Prot healing skill you pre-use it on like someone who is getting attacked pretty much...
Keep calling people with Mending noobs, well Mending made the best runner builds...
I remember a topic that had the discussion: WoH dead GL the new Monk Elite in HA?
Haha u use Remove Hex, I'm pro I use Veil...hmm we have NR in our build, hell yeah Remove Hex is better then...
just to say... Skills have their uses, don't try to take certain skills down cause they 'suck' according to you... Say that to Necro Raiders...
The fact is, if ure r3 and u say: let me use Rejuvenation on a WoH monk(example) they are mostly like... NO! We want to play like R6 and R9 lets run LoD's... I bet that if I play WoH I play better then when using LoD cause WoH is nearly 70% experience to all Monks in Halls which means u play better with that skill...
Yesterday observed Clan Detained vs Helis Galonia Commando Elite(#6)... The #6 had a Mo/E LoD WITH Healing Breeze!
So stop saying that skill X is better then skill Y <3 Burst Cancel, just keep that for yourself and experience your own experience instead of asking other players
|
|
|
Jan 09, 2007, 03:09 PM // 15:09
|
#56
|
Forge Runner
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Thornill, ON, Canada
Guild: THE CANUCK MONKS (TCM)
Profession: W/R
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Flashy
haha lovely discussion here
Skills are made to use, you can make a nice bar out of it, it is called non Gimmick
Healing Breeze? Why not? Give me 1 ****ing good reason why not? Cause you think ure better then the guy using it? Be happy that people use it, nearly makes u 1 of the best monks
Healing Breeze is a sort of Prot healing skill you pre-use it on like someone who is getting attacked pretty much...
Keep calling people with Mending noobs, well Mending made the best runner builds...
I remember a topic that had the discussion: WoH dead GL the new Monk Elite in HA?
Haha u use Remove Hex, I'm pro I use Veil...hmm we have NR in our build, hell yeah Remove Hex is better then...
just to say... Skills have their uses, don't try to take certain skills down cause they 'suck' according to you... Say that to Necro Raiders...
The fact is, if ure r3 and u say: let me use Rejuvenation on a WoH monk(example) they are mostly like... NO! We want to play like R6 and R9 lets run LoD's... I bet that if I play WoH I play better then when using LoD cause WoH is nearly 70% experience to all Monks in Halls which means u play better with that skill...
Yesterday observed Clan Detained vs Helis Galonia Commando Elite(#6)... The #6 had a Mo/E LoD WITH Healing Breeze!
So stop saying that skill X is better then skill Y <3 Burst Cancel, just keep that for yourself and experience your own experience instead of asking other players
|
Please tell me that you were being sarcastic about HB and Mending.
|
|
|
Jan 09, 2007, 04:47 PM // 16:47
|
#57
|
Desert Nomad
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Domain of Broken Game Mechanics
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Flashy
haha lovely discussion here
Skills are made to use, you can make a nice bar out of it, it is called non Gimmick
Healing Breeze? Why not? Give me 1 ****ing good reason why not? Cause you think ure better then the guy using it? Be happy that people use it, nearly makes u 1 of the best monks
Healing Breeze is a sort of Prot healing skill you pre-use it on like someone who is getting attacked pretty much...
Keep calling people with Mending noobs, well Mending made the best runner builds...
I remember a topic that had the discussion: WoH dead GL the new Monk Elite in HA?
Haha u use Remove Hex, I'm pro I use Veil...hmm we have NR in our build, hell yeah Remove Hex is better then...
just to say... Skills have their uses, don't try to take certain skills down cause they 'suck' according to you... Say that to Necro Raiders...
The fact is, if ure r3 and u say: let me use Rejuvenation on a WoH monk(example) they are mostly like... NO! We want to play like R6 and R9 lets run LoD's... I bet that if I play WoH I play better then when using LoD cause WoH is nearly 70% experience to all Monks in Halls which means u play better with that skill...
Yesterday observed Clan Detained vs Helis Galonia Commando Elite(#6)... The #6 had a Mo/E LoD WITH Healing Breeze!
So stop saying that skill X is better then skill Y <3 Burst Cancel, just keep that for yourself and experience your own experience instead of asking other players
|
Die in a fire.
The reason why most of the GW community never gets better is because they are all vapid scrubs like you. Good players spoonfeed excellent advice to you on a daily basis, but the vast majority of you are too stupid to even swallow. Did you even read the damn thread? If you did, you'd already have your reason for why Healing Breeze sucks, instead of making a complete idiot out of yourself here.
|
|
|
Jan 09, 2007, 09:11 PM // 21:11
|
#58
|
Banned
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: American District 1
Guild: NDR|||We are recruiting|||PM me
|
@flashy: please, i mean P L E A S E, shut up. you might even be more annoying than legendary ultimatum... *gasp*
and guys, i was talking about end of game mission where theres heal monk and prot monk, i wanna heal, but another question is that what if a certain area/mission needs only 1 monk, heal or prot? if u say prot, what if ur protting and someone gets uber spiked. isnt that what healing is for?
@effigy: show me a good (in your eyes) protty build with heal and prot. spreading out 3 attributes wont help, unless u mean healing with prot skills like ZB, but ZB as ur elite would deprive u of actual protecting elites from prot. just show me a "nice" build.
|
|
|
Jan 09, 2007, 11:28 PM // 23:28
|
#59
|
Desert Nomad
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Domain of Broken Game Mechanics
|
Here is your nice hybrid build:
ZB
RoF
GoH
SB/PS
SoA/SoD
Holy Veil
Mend/Dismiss Condition
Rebirth/GoLE
As for 'uber spiked':
1) There aren't that many areas in PvE that feature spikes.
2) There are even fewer PvE spikes that can't be preprotted.
Prot vs. Heal is the "ounce of prevention > pound of repair" situation. Healing is better at making red bars go up. Prot is better at keeping those red bars up to begin with. Most beginners prefer heal because it allows them to glue their eyes to the party window and juice people that take damage. This is, in fact, a terrible way to monk. As you get better at the game, you realize that if you can prevent that 300 damage boss fireball from actually doing 300 damage, you won't have to worry about healing through it. Unfortunately, the average GW player isn't able to do this reliably because it actually requires you to have a brain and some meaningful game experience. The party window no longer works as the Complete Idiot's Guide to Monking, because you have to put down your prots before the damage actually hits.
Played incorrectly, prot just isn't very effective. Prot Spirit on the ele after the boss flattens her with a 300-point Devastating is a waste of energy. So if you're not smart enough to figure out where the prots need to go, and when they need to get there, feel free to keep on healing.
|
|
|
Jan 09, 2007, 11:28 PM // 23:28
|
#60
|
Just Plain Fluffy
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Berkeley, CA
Guild: Idiot Savants
|
You will see Healing Breeze used in competitive GvG. The reason is because sometimes you're Healing specced for Party / LoD, and want a heal that you can use on both yourself and teammates / NPCs. The problem being that there isn't one. Go look. Unless you're spending your elite there's no good, general purpose heal in the healing line. So people turn to Healing Breeze, because it does target you or an ally, you can get full milage out of the regen in small fights (though never in big fights), and, well, it's all you have.
Because healing is pretty bad.
Peace,
-CxE
__________________
Don't argue with idiots. They bring you to their level and beat you with experience.
|
|
|
Thread Tools |
|
Display Modes |
Linear Mode
|
Posting Rules
|
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off
|
|
|
All times are GMT. The time now is 04:10 AM // 04:10.
|